Feds Consider Tightening Grip on Puppy Mills

Toledo Blade (OH)

July 12, 2012

The U.S. Department of Agriculture is considering broadening its legal reach to regulate more dog breeders and sellers to curb “puppy mills.”

The proposed federal rule change would alter the definition of “retail pet store” and bring many puppy mills that are not licensed and inspected under the jurisdiction of the Animal Welfare Act, a federal law that protects animals kept by dealers, exhibitors and research facilities.

Humane societies around the country have mounted a concerted lobbying campaign, asking citizens to support the change. The USDA is taking comments on the proposal through July 16.

The rules now state that some high-volume breeders—some of which would be considered puppy mills—must be licensed and inspected, but only if they sell their dogs wholesale. Breeders who sell retail or directly to the public are exempt from licensing and inspection because they fall under the current definition of “retail pet store.”

“The proposed rule change will redefine ‘retail pet store’ as a store where pet buyers see pets prior to purchasing them,” said John Dinon, executive director of the Toledo Area Humane Society “Changing the rule would mean that high volume breeders who sell directly to the public over the internet, by mail or at swap meets would have to be licensed and inspected by the USDA.”

National groups that also support the new definition include the Humane Society of the United States and the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (APSCA). The Humane Society said the rule change would “close a gaping loophole in the Animal Welfare Act regulations.”

The change is in response to concerns about thousands of dogs denied basic humane care at large-scale commercial breeding facilities, according to the Humane Society.

“Industries that profit from mass-producing puppies are vociferously opposing the rule, alleging that it will cause businesses unnecessary expense to provide basic humane care for dogs,” the society said. “Providing humane care and safe housing for dogs is not a burden, but a fundamental responsibility.”

According to the ASPCA, the proposed rule represents a “meaningful effort by the USDA to target problematic, large-scale breeding operations and would require them to meet minimum-care standards for breeding dogs and the puppies they produce.” The group is optimistic the rule change will strike a balance by excluding hobby breeders and targeting inhumane breeding facilities.

“The online sales exemption was created before the advent of the internet under the presumption that a consumer buying a puppy directly from a breeder could personally assess the welfare of the dogs on site,” said Nancy Perry, senior vice president of ASPCA Government Relations. “It was impossible to foresee that consumers would one day purchase pets online and have puppies shipped to them, sight unseen.”

The ASPCA’s “No Pet Store Puppies” campaign at NoPetStorePuppies.com aims to reduce the demand for puppy-mill puppies by urging consumers to pledge not to buy any items—including food, supplies, or toys—from stores or websites that sell puppies.